Jumping the Gun on CCD
I just emailed Kim Flottum, editor of Bee Culture magazine and a wonderful blog on beekeeping in The Daily Green. I asked him about a book that came out this spring about Colony Collapse Disorder, titled A Spring Without Bees, by Michael Schacker. I found this book quite illuminating, especially because it pointed to a specific cause of CCD: An insecticide called Imadacloprid (IMD) produced by Bayer Industries. In the book, Schacker makes the argument that IMD is responsible for CCD, and argues that we need to remove the pesticide from our agricultural production.
Now, I'm an organic fan all the way, but I also wondered how Schacker was able to be so confident about his conclusion when I hadn't really come across anyone else as confident in my research. So, this led to my email to the esteemed Mr. Flottum, and he had an interesting comment to make. He said that he felt Schacker jumped the gun, essentially, about IMD as the cause of CCD (could I get anymore acronyms here?). He felt that there was a lot of evidence supporting CCD being caused by a pathogen, not a chemical.
However, Mr. Flottum went on to say that he did feel that those pesticides and chemicals were contributing to the worst of the honey bee issues they were facing, and that some recent research has pointed to IMD as one of the major honeybee threats as well.
Well, I have to say that I was a little bummed to hear him downplay a definitive answer, but I think his hesitation is important. I really and truly believe that we have to change our agricultural system all together, that it's unsustainable, and that it should begin with pesticides. However, I also think it's important to fully investigate the situation before making hasty conclusions. To me, that is bad science and bad environmental management. But--more than anything, I think it just represents the fear we have that this is a huge dilemma and that we have to do something to act quickly, before we suffer a loss that might be too crippling for the honeybee industry to bear.
(P.S. You can see me jump the gun in an earlier blog here. Feeling sheepish. :)
Now, I'm an organic fan all the way, but I also wondered how Schacker was able to be so confident about his conclusion when I hadn't really come across anyone else as confident in my research. So, this led to my email to the esteemed Mr. Flottum, and he had an interesting comment to make. He said that he felt Schacker jumped the gun, essentially, about IMD as the cause of CCD (could I get anymore acronyms here?). He felt that there was a lot of evidence supporting CCD being caused by a pathogen, not a chemical.
However, Mr. Flottum went on to say that he did feel that those pesticides and chemicals were contributing to the worst of the honey bee issues they were facing, and that some recent research has pointed to IMD as one of the major honeybee threats as well.
Well, I have to say that I was a little bummed to hear him downplay a definitive answer, but I think his hesitation is important. I really and truly believe that we have to change our agricultural system all together, that it's unsustainable, and that it should begin with pesticides. However, I also think it's important to fully investigate the situation before making hasty conclusions. To me, that is bad science and bad environmental management. But--more than anything, I think it just represents the fear we have that this is a huge dilemma and that we have to do something to act quickly, before we suffer a loss that might be too crippling for the honeybee industry to bear.
(P.S. You can see me jump the gun in an earlier blog here. Feeling sheepish. :)
Add a Comment
About
Latest Activity
Hi, Lori:
Sorry to read about your defeat... it seems we may have many common campaigning experiences to share!
I too was first time candidate for Town Council, in Clifton Park, NY. http://sites.google.com/site/zygmuntowiczfortowncouncil/
Congr...
Vote. Run. Lead. Shop.
Pick up your Closing the Leadership Gap book and Ms. President T-Shirts while they're in stock!Go >
Events
-
Community Care Plus Pageant
July 3, 2010 at 6pm to July 4, 2010 at 10pm – The Orleans
-
A man is Not a Financial Plan
October 31, 2010 from 8am to 3pm – Drexel University, ,
Get a badge for The White House Project!
Disclaimer
The White House Project (WHP) provides this site as a service to its members, to those interested in women's leadership, and to the public, in furtherance of WHP's mission as a 501(c)(3) nonpartisan, not-for-profit organization.
WHP is not responsible for, and expressly disclaims all liability for, damages of any kind arising out of use, reference to, or reliance on any information contained within the site. While the information contained within the site is periodically updated, no guarantee is given that the information provided in this Web site is correct, complete, and up-to-date.
Although WHP's Web site may include links providing direct access to other Internet resources, including Web sites, WHP has not participated in the development of those other sites and does not exert any editorial or other control over those sites. WHP is not responsible for the accuracy or content of information contained in these sites.
Links from WHP to third-party sites does not constitute an endorsement by WHP of the sites, organizations, or their products and services. The appearance on the Web site of advertisements and product or service information does not constitute an endorsement by WHP, and WHP has not investigated the claims made by any advertiser.
Opinions expressed by contributors to this site are not necessarily those of WHP.
Opinions
The opinions expressed by contributors to the WHP site are solely those of the individual writers and do not reflect the opinions of WHP, the members of WHP, the WHP board of directors, WHP corporate council members, volunteers, or individuals associate with WHP.
Endorsements
Reference herein to any specific person, candidate, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by WHP, the members of WHP, the WHP board of directors, WHP corporate council members, volunteers, or individuals associate with WHP.
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY: WHP and its licensors own the copyright to the Site, which is protected by United States copyright law. No user may reproduce, distribute, modify, download or otherwise use any content on the Site for any purpose other personal use or as expressly permitted, without the prior written permission of WHP. WHP owns all rights to its name and logo, which are protected by trademark law and are registered with the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
WHP is not responsible for, and expressly disclaims all liability for, damages of any kind arising out of use, reference to, or reliance on any information contained within the site. While the information contained within the site is periodically updated, no guarantee is given that the information provided in this Web site is correct, complete, and up-to-date.
Although WHP's Web site may include links providing direct access to other Internet resources, including Web sites, WHP has not participated in the development of those other sites and does not exert any editorial or other control over those sites. WHP is not responsible for the accuracy or content of information contained in these sites.
Links from WHP to third-party sites does not constitute an endorsement by WHP of the sites, organizations, or their products and services. The appearance on the Web site of advertisements and product or service information does not constitute an endorsement by WHP, and WHP has not investigated the claims made by any advertiser.
Opinions expressed by contributors to this site are not necessarily those of WHP.
Opinions
The opinions expressed by contributors to the WHP site are solely those of the individual writers and do not reflect the opinions of WHP, the members of WHP, the WHP board of directors, WHP corporate council members, volunteers, or individuals associate with WHP.
Endorsements
Reference herein to any specific person, candidate, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by WHP, the members of WHP, the WHP board of directors, WHP corporate council members, volunteers, or individuals associate with WHP.
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY: WHP and its licensors own the copyright to the Site, which is protected by United States copyright law. No user may reproduce, distribute, modify, download or otherwise use any content on the Site for any purpose other personal use or as expressly permitted, without the prior written permission of WHP. WHP owns all rights to its name and logo, which are protected by trademark law and are registered with the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
© 2009 Created by The White House Project on Ning. Create a Ning Network!
You must sign up and become a White House Project Leader to add comments!
Join this network